A mystery by mail for two

The Love Letters That Were Never Delivered

A 6-week mystery that arrives in your mailbox. One sealed envelope a week. Two sets of clues. Only together can you find out what happened.

Begin Your Mystery: $99

Free US shipping · Money-back promise · Makes a great gift

A bundle of old letters tied with a faded ribbon, an old key and a seashell on a wooden table

How it begins

Key West, Florida.

A bundle of letters is found hidden behind a wall in an old house.

They're tied with a faded ribbon. Signed only E. and J.

Someone hid them there on purpose.

"If you are reading this, then I never made it to the lighthouse. Please, find J. Tell her I kept my promise..."

The letter on top stops in the middle of a sentence.

Now the letters are coming to you, one week at a time.

Two people at a table with red wine, each holding a clue card, letters between them

Made for two

Every envelope holds two sealed clue cards, one for each of you.

You each hold half of the answer.

Read the letters out loud. Compare your clues. Argue a little. Solve it together.

It's date night that shows up in your mailbox, six weeks in a row.

What arrives

Six sealed envelopes with old letters, a telegram, a steamship ticket, a torn photograph of a lighthouse, a map and clue cards laid out on a table
  • The letters themselves, in the order they were found. Not the order they were written.
  • A telegram with a message that doesn't add up.
  • A steamship ticket with something written on the back.
  • A photograph torn in half. Each of you gets one half.
  • A coded message and an old map of the island.
  • A sealed hint in every envelope, in case you get stuck.

The final envelope tells you what really happened. It also holds stationery for each of you to write the other a letter of your own.

How it works

  1. You order. Tell us the names to put on the envelopes and where to send them.
  2. The envelopes arrive. One a week for 6 weeks, addressed to both of you.
  3. You solve it together. Open it on your own schedule. Each week brings you closer to the truth.

Giving it as a gift?

At checkout, type CHRISTMAS where it asks when to start. We'll email you a printable invitation within a day, ready to wrap and put under the tree.

The letters start arriving in January, so the romance keeps going after the holidays.

Or type NOW, and your first letter mails within 2 weeks.

The price

$99

Free US shipping. One payment. No subscription.

That covers 6 sealed envelopes, 12 clue cards, the letters, the telegram, the steamship ticket, the torn photograph, the coded message, the map, 6 sealed hints and the finale stationery.

Our promise

If you don't love the first letter, email us within 7 days of it arriving. We'll refund you in full and stop the rest.

Every envelope is printed, sealed and packed by hand, so we take only 25 couples at a time.

Begin your mystery

Send it to the address where you'll open it together.

US shipping

Free


Your Details

Email

First name

Last name

Buying this as a gift? Who is it from? (optional).

When should it start? Type NOW (first letter within 2 weeks) or CHRISTMAS (gift invitation now, letters in January).

Names for the envelopes (both of you)

Ship to the address where you’ll open it.

Street address (include apt. or unit)

City

State

Zip

Country

US shipping

Free

Payment

Secure checkout · Backed by The Love Letter Promise

Questions

Do we need to be good at puzzles?
No. The clues are fun, not frustrating. Every envelope has a sealed hint if you get stuck.
Is it romantic or a mystery?
Both. It's a real mystery with a love story at its heart, and it ends with the two of you writing to each other.
Can two friends do it together?
Yes. Any two people who like a good mystery. Just put both names on the order.
When does it start?
At checkout, type NOW (first letter mails within 2 weeks) or CHRISTMAS (letters start in January).
Do you ship outside the US?
Not yet. US addresses only.

P.S. Most date nights are forgotten by the next weekend. This one arrives six times, gives you something to solve side by side, and ends with a letter from each of you to the other. We take only 25 couples at a time, and our money-back promise means you risk nothing.

"Find J. Tell her I kept my promise."